Planned Parenthood Closures: A Crisis for Black Women
By Darius Spearman (africanelements)
Support African Elements at patreon.com/africanelements and hear recent news in a single playlist. Additionally, you can gain early access to ad-free video content.
Planned Parenthood: Organizational Shifts and Political Pressures
Planned Parenthood Gulf Coast (PPGC), an independent affiliate of the national Planned Parenthood organization, is ceasing operations this fall (newsone.com). This decision includes the closure of its Louisiana clinics and two Houston clinics (newsone.com). Planned Parenthood of Greater Texas will assume control of four other Houston clinics (newsone.com). This move is part of an “organizational restructure” aimed at consolidating services and minimizing patient impact (houstonpublicmedia.org).
The restructuring is a direct result of sustained political attacks and legislative challenges in Texas (houstonpublicmedia.org). These efforts have aimed to eliminate Planned Parenthood organizations from state-funded health programs (houstonpublicmedia.org). For instance, Planned Parenthood stopped providing abortions in Texas in 2022 following the implementation of Senate Bill 8 (houstonpublicmedia.org). Anti-abortion leaders, including Louisiana Governor Jeff Landry, have celebrated this news (newsone.com). However, these closures raise significant concerns about access to essential healthcare services, especially for marginalized communities.
The Critical Role of Public Funding in Healthcare Access
The closure of Planned Parenthood clinics, particularly those serving a significant number of publicly funded patients, could have devastating consequences for communities (plannedparenthood.org). Approximately 53% of Planned Parenthood patients receive care through publicly funded programs like Medicaid or Title X (plannedparenthood.org). Medicaid is a joint federal and state program that provides health coverage to millions of low-income Americans (kff.org). Title X is a federal grant program specifically dedicated to providing comprehensive family planning and related preventive health services to low-income and uninsured individuals (kff.org).
These programs are critical because they enable clinics to offer affordable or free services to a significant portion of their patient base (kff.org). In 2023, about 36% of all Title X services were provided by Planned Parenthood clinics (nbcnews.com). Eliminating these funding sources could cut hundreds of millions of dollars from Planned Parenthood’s care costs annually, impacting all clinics regardless of whether they offer abortion services (nbcnews.com). Two out of three patients in a previous survey reported that publicly funded health centers, like Planned Parenthood, were their primary source of medical care (plannedparenthood.org).
Patient Funding and Primary Care Sources
Disproportionate Impact on Black Women and Marginalized Communities
The defunding of Planned Parenthood disproportionately impacts marginalized communities, especially Black women (wordinblack.com). Over 38% of patients receiving care at Planned Parenthood Gulf Coast in FY24 were Black (newsone.com). In many areas, Planned Parenthood is the sole provider and the only entry point to the healthcare system for many Black women and other individuals (wordinblack.com). The impact of defunding Planned Parenthood, combined with Medicaid cuts, will be most severe in states with abortion bans in the South and Midwest (wordinblack.com).
The closure of clinics means that patients will lose access to specific services, potentially facing longer travel times, increased costs, or a complete lack of alternative providers (guttmacher.org). Other publicly supported clinics, such as Federally Qualified Health Centers (FQHCs), would struggle to absorb the patient volume (guttmacher.org). In nine states, FQHCs and other publicly supported clinics would need to increase their caseloads by more than 100% to provide care for patients currently served by Planned Parenthood (guttmacher.org). This creates a significant gap in the healthcare safety net, making it harder for vulnerable populations to access essential care.
Beyond Abortion: Essential Healthcare Services
Planned Parenthood provides essential basic health care services beyond abortion, and defunding efforts are often a tactic to restrict abortion access (nbcnews.com). Planned Parenthood clinics offer a wide range of basic health care services, including contraception, STI testing and treatment, cancer screenings, and general reproductive health exams (nbcnews.com). If these clinics close, many women will struggle to find alternative providers (nbcnews.com).
Targeting federal funding for Planned Parenthood is a way for opponents of abortion rights to attempt to shut down clinics that provide abortion, even if those funds cannot directly cover abortion procedures (nbcnews.com). Planned Parenthood Gulf Coast provided over $4 million in financial assistance to under- and uninsured patients (newsone.com). The idea that tax dollars fund abortion is not true (plannedparenthood.org). This is generally due to federal restrictions like the Hyde Amendment, which prohibits the use of federal funds for abortion services, except in cases of rape, incest, or to save the life of the pregnant person. Planned Parenthood Gulf Coast cannot provide abortion services in Texas or Louisiana but offers medically accurate information, pregnancy testing, options counseling, and assistance connecting patients to out-of-state abortion care with financial aid for travel (plannedparenthood.org).
Key Services Provided by Planned Parenthood Gulf Coast
Maternal Health and Healthcare Disparities
The closure of Planned Parenthood clinics could exacerbate existing healthcare disparities and negatively impact maternal health outcomes (newsone.com). Previously reported delays in routine prenatal care could worsen due to the closures (newsone.com). A report highlighted a dangerous disruption in standard pregnancy care in post-abortion ban Louisiana, with 16.2% of birthing people receiving inadequate prenatal care (newsone.com).
Over a quarter of parishes in Louisiana were defined as maternity care deserts (newsone.com). A “maternity care desert” refers to a county where access to maternity healthcare services is limited or non-existent. This can include a lack of obstetric providers, birthing centers, or hospitals offering obstetric care. These areas often have higher rates of adverse maternal and infant health outcomes. The closure of clinics in such regions will only deepen these existing crises, making it harder for pregnant individuals to receive the care they need.
Maternal Care Access in Louisiana
The Broader Implications of Clinic Closures
The decision to reduce PPGC’s footprint is a direct result of sustained political attacks in Texas, which have aimed to eliminate the organizations from state-funded health programs (houstonpublicmedia.org). This situation underscores a larger political battle where reproductive rights are under constant threat. The impact of these closures extends beyond the immediate loss of services; it creates a chilling effect on healthcare providers and patients alike.
The ongoing efforts to defund Planned Parenthood and restrict abortion access are part of a broader strategy to control reproductive freedom. Melaney Lipton, President and CEO of Planned Parenthood Gulf Coast, framed the organization’s work in the context of supporting freedom, stating that the opposition's tactics threaten the freedom to manage sexual and reproductive health, plan a future, and control one's own body (newsone.com). This perspective highlights the fundamental human rights at stake in these political battles.
Navigating the Future of Reproductive Healthcare
The closure of Planned Parenthood clinics raises critical questions about where patients will seek care, whether other providers can absorb the demand, and what barriers patients might face in accessing alternative care. Six in ten patients who receive care at a women's health center like Planned Parenthood consider it their main source of health care (plannedparenthood.org). If Planned Parenthood did not receive funding for health services, millions would have to search for alternative providers for these lifesaving services (plannedparenthood.org).
Asking FQHCs to become the main source of publicly funded family planning care in the United States is not a viable policy proposal, especially amidst efforts to cut Medicaid and eliminate Title X (guttmacher.org). The current situation demands a comprehensive approach to ensure that all individuals, especially those in marginalized communities, have access to the full range of reproductive healthcare services. This includes advocating for robust public funding, expanding the network of accessible providers, and combating legislative efforts that undermine healthcare access.
ABOUT THE AUTHOR
Darius Spearman has been a professor of Black Studies at San Diego City College since 2007. He is the author of several books, including Between The Color Lines: A History of African Americans on the California Frontier Through 1890. You can visit Darius online at africanelements.org.
