Justice for Kelaia Turner Highlights Urgent Need to Combat School Bullying

By Darius Spearman (africanelements)

Support African Elements at patreon.com/africanelements and hear recent news in a single playlist. Additionally, you can gain early access to ad-free video content.

KEY TAKEAWAYS
Kelaia Turner was subjected to relentless bullying, leading to a suicide attempt.
Teachers and school officials failed to intervene in the bullying incidents.
Kelaia now requires round-the-clock care due to severe brain damage from the suicide attempt.
The lawsuit filed against the school district alleges violations of constitutional rights.
The school district has largely denied the allegations and claims legal immunity.
Kelaia’s case emphasizes the need for systemic change in educational environments.

Systemic Racism in Schools: The Tragic Situation of Kelaia Turner

Kelaia Turner, a 12-year-old student, faced intense bullying at Dr. Phinnize J. Fisher Middle School in South Carolina. This continued harassment led to a suicide attempt on March 18, 2023, resulting in severe brain damage and her reliance on life-supporting devices.

The bullying was not limited to normal school taunts. Students mocked her with racial insults and transphobic comments, calling her names like “a man,” “a roach,” “Trans,” and more. Teachers, who witnessed these events, didn’t stop the abuse or address this discrimination.

Teacher Complicity and Institutional Failure

Shockingly, some teachers participated. In December 2021, teacher Olivia Bennett let students insult Kelaia and even joined them by pointing when asked, “Where’s the roach?” This example of teacher involvement shows the deep racism within the school system.

School officials ignored many complaints from Kelaia’s mother, Ty Turner. When Kelaia was suspended after a fight in March 2022, the student who caused it faced no punishment, highlighting administrative negligence.

Racial Insensitivity and Cultural Ignorance

On May 23, 2022, in teacher John Teer’s class, a student played a YouTube video called “The Black People Song.” Teer didn’t address its offensiveness, showing his lack of cultural awareness. Sections of the school encouraged harmful stereotypes instead of inclusivity.

This atmosphere stresses the importance of anti-racism training and education for all staff, ensuring students of all races feel safe and respected.

The Devastating Consequences of Unchecked Bullying

The bullying and neglect pushed Kelaia to try to end her life on March 18, 2023. Her life now involves constant care because of the severe damage caused. This situation shows the serious effects of unchecked racial bullying and neglect within schools.

Kelaia’s experience highlights the education system’s failure to support vulnerable students, especially from marginalized communities. It points to the need for real changes and accountability within schools.

Legal Action and the Fight for Justice

Kelaia’s parents sued the Greenville County School District and involved teachers for violating equal protection laws and Title IX gender protections. Their lawsuit calls attention to the mix of racial and gender bias Kelaia endured.

This legal action is a crucial move toward holding schools accountable. By pursuing this lawsuit, her family aims to secure justice for Kelaia and others facing similar discrimination.

The School District’s Inadequate Response

The Greenville County School District has denied most claims against it. Their defense cites legal technicalities, such as immunity under state law, reflecting a lack of willingness to acknowledge systemic issues.

The district claims it conducted “thorough investigations,” but Kelaia’s ongoing ordeal disputes this. Their stance exemplifies a broader reluctance to tackle racism in schools.

Understanding Systemic Racism

The Role of Teachers and School Policies

Teachers play a vital role in creating a safe environment for students. They have a responsibility to recognize and address bullying and discrimination in their classrooms. When educators like Olivia Bennett and John Teer fail to intervene or, worse, participate in harassment, they breach their duty to protect students (Cognitive Research: Principles and Implications).

Moreover, schools must implement policies that promote equity and inclusion. These policies should include clear procedures for reporting and addressing bullying and discrimination. Training in cultural competency can help staff understand and respect diverse backgrounds, reducing instances of bias (Inclusive Princeton).

Legal Frameworks: Equal Protection and Sovereign Immunity

The Equal Protection Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment mandates that states must not deny any person equal protection under the law. This clause aims to prevent discrimination based on characteristics like race or gender (Health Affairs). In Kelaia’s case, the lawsuit alleges that the school district violated this constitutional right by allowing discriminatory practices to persist.

However, the concept of sovereign immunity can complicate legal actions against government entities like school districts. Sovereign immunity is a legal doctrine that protects government bodies from certain lawsuits unless they consent to be sued. This defense can limit the ability of individuals to hold institutions accountable (OHCHR).

The Impact of Legal Action on Systemic Change

Lawsuits like the one filed by Kelaia’s parents can drive significant changes within educational institutions. By holding schools accountable through the legal system, such actions can lead to policy reforms and increased awareness of systemic racism. These legal challenges reveal the need for schools to implement effective anti-discrimination policies and practices (Health Affairs).

Furthermore, these cases can set precedents that influence other districts and prompt wider reforms. When schools are compelled to address systemic issues, it benefits individual students and contributes to a more equitable education system for all (Cognitive Research: Principles and Implications).

Understanding systemic racism and its impact on students like Kelaia is essential. Teachers, administrators, and policymakers must work together to create safe and inclusive schools. Legal actions play an important role in exposing failures and prompting the necessary changes to protect all students.

The Imperative for Systemic Change

Kelaia Turner’s situation highlights the urgent need for significant reforms in American schools. Racism and lack of accountability are not isolated problems but represent a broken system marginalizing Black students and minority groups.

As her case proceeds, it’s vital for society to push for justice and demand changes to prevent such tragedies. Fighting racism in schools requires more than anti-bullying policies or diversity efforts; it demands overhauling systems upholding white supremacy.

Through sustained activism and a commitment to real progress, we can hope to build a school system serving all students fairly. Kelaia’s story must ignite this essential change.

FAQ

Q: Who is Kelaia Turner and what happened to her?
A: Kelaia Turner is a 12-year-old Black student who faced persistent bullying at Dr. Phinnize J. Fisher Middle School, culminating in a suicide attempt on March 18, 2023, that resulted in severe brain damage.

Q: What type of bullying did Kelaia experience?
A: Kelaia was subjected to racial slurs and transphobic taunts by her peers, including derogatory names like “a roach” and “Mustache Face,” all while teachers failed to intervene.

Q: How did the school administration respond to Kelaia’s situation?
A: Despite multiple complaints from Kelaia’s mother, the school administration neglected to take appropriate action, including suspending Kelaia after a fight while the instigator faced no consequences.

Q: What legal actions have been taken?
A: Kelaia’s parents have filed a lawsuit against the Greenville County School District, alleging violations of the Equal Protection Clause and Title IX protections against gender discrimination.

Q: What does this case signify for the education system?
A: The case highlights the urgent need for systemic reform in schools to address racism and support marginalized students, as well as the importance of accountability and meaningful change from educational institutions.

Q: What can be done to prevent similar tragedies?
A: Comprehensive anti-racism training for staff, along with a commitment to cultural competency and systemic change, is necessary to create a safe and inclusive environment for all students.

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Darius Spearman is a professor of Black Studies at San Diego City College, where he has been teaching since 2007. He is the author of several books, including Between The Color Lines: A History of African Americans on the California Frontier Through 1890. You can visit Darius online at africanelements.org.