Listen to this article
Download AudioEnd Racial Harassment in Education Through Systemic Change
By Darius Spearman (africanelements)
Support African Elements at patreon.com/africanelements and hear recent news in a single playlist. Additionally, you can gain early access to ad-free video content.
| KEY TAKEAWAYS |
|---|
| The Hodge family is suing the West Ada School District for racial discrimination. |
| Both daughters faced systemic racial harassment, with staff being indifferent. |
| The lawsuit highlights broader issues of racial disparities in education. |
| Financial compensation is sought for emotional and educational harm. |
| The family is advocating for training on racial and gender-based harassment. |
| This case serves as a catalyst for accountability in educational systems. |
The Scourge of Racial Harassment in Schools
The Hodge family from Eagle, Idaho, takes a courageous stand against racial discrimination in American schools. They filed a lawsuit against the West Ada School District and other local authorities. This reveals the harmful racism that still exists in education.
Racial Harassment in Schools (2019)
Black Students
White Students
In 2019, about 25% of Black students aged 12-18 reported being bullied at school, compared to about 22% of White students.
Their daughters, Jaeyden and A.H., have faced ongoing racist acts at Eagle High School since 2021. The discrimination worsened, not only from peers alone but also from those responsible for their education. An incident involved a teacher accusing A.H. of inappropriate behavior without cause. This accusation led to social isolation and verbal harassment. Another teacher used racial slurs in class, making it seem acceptable to students.
The School’s Complicity in Perpetuating Discrimination
The lawsuit shows a failure in the school system at many levels. When the sisters sought help from the school officer, they were told to ignore the harassment. This careless response shows the apathy allowing racial discrimination to continue.
Administrators knew of these incidents yet chose not to investigate them, claims the lawsuit. This inaction violates the care owed to students, signaling racism is tolerated at school.
The Broader Picture of Racial Disparities in Education
The Hodge family’s struggle is part of a bigger issue in the American education system. Research shows Black students often receive harsher punishment for similar actions as their peers. Unequal treatment starts early, leading to lifelong educational gaps.
Disciplinary Actions in Schools (2019–2020)
Black Students
White Students
In the 2019–2020 school year, Black students had a 12.8% out-of-school suspension rate, compared to 4.3% among White students.
Despite awareness, racial disparity in discipline has persisted or worsened over the decades. This reinforces how deeply rooted racism is in schools and highlights the urgent need for meaningful change.
The Impact of Racial Harassment on Students
Racial harassment impacts students beyond immediate emotional stress. A.H. and Jaeyden experienced educational setbacks and psychological harm. Their lawsuit seeks financial compensation for these damages.
Yet, money alone cannot undo the harm or regain lost learning opportunities. The lawsuit insists on recognizing the actual costs of racial discrimination.
Understanding Systemic Racism in Education
To fully grasp the Hodge family’s struggle, we must understand systemic racism in education. This form of racism is embedded in the policies and practices of schools, disadvantaging students from underrepresented communities. It is not always obvious; often, it appears in subtle ways that are hard to spot. For instance, schools with mostly non-white students often receive less funding and have fewer resources. Moreover, Black students frequently face harsher punishments than their peers for similar behaviors. These disparities are rooted in the very structure of the educational system (Understanding Systemic Racism in Education | Robert F. Smith).
What Is Systemic Racism?
Systemic Racism: When policies and practices within institutions unfairly harm certain groups. Unlike personal prejudice, it exists in social, economic, and political systems around us. Recognizing it is key to addressing the root causes of racial inequalities in education.
The Legal Pathways to Challenging Discrimination
The Hodge family’s lawsuit highlights the role of legal action in fighting systemic racism. When schools fail to address discrimination internally, lawsuits become a vital tool. Moreover, legal actions can challenge unfair policies and practices, pushing for reforms that promote equality. They often involve collecting data to prove disparities, such as differences in disciplinary measures against Black students. Consequently, these cases can lead to significant changes, like requiring anti-bias training for educators. Through the legal system, individuals can hold institutions accountable and demand justice (Understanding Systemic Racism in Education | Robert F. Smith).
The Importance of Harassment Training in Schools
One of the key demands in the lawsuit is for racial and gender-based harassment training for all school employees. This type of training educates staff about the issues of racism and gender-based violence. Its purpose is to prevent harassment before it happens and to create a more inclusive environment. Furthermore, training programs often include bystander intervention techniques, helping staff to recognize and address problematic behaviors. By promoting awareness and understanding, these programs aim to reduce incidents of discrimination and foster a safer school climate (Preventing Gender-Based Harassment and Violence Learning Circles).
Anti-bias training can help educators challenge their own assumptions and better support students from diverse backgrounds. It encourages fair and consistent accountability, ensuring that all students are treated with respect. Therefore, by implementing such training, schools take a proactive step toward dismantling systemic racism within their institutions (Understanding Systemic Racism in Education | Robert F. Smith).
Community Actions to Address Systemic Racism
Dismantling systemic racism requires the involvement of individuals and communities alike. For example, educators can build genuine relationships with students and advocate for those from underrepresented groups. Completing anti-bias training and supporting leadership diversity within schools are important steps. Additionally, communities can participate in initiatives like learning circles and response teams to promote policies that prevent harassment and violence. By working together, we can support policy reforms that address inequities, such as unequal funding and lack of diverse curricula. Ultimately, these actions help create an educational environment where all students have the opportunity to thrive (Understanding Systemic Racism in Education | Robert F. Smith).
Challenging Systemic Racism
The Hodge family’s lawsuit is not just about personal justice; it challenges ongoing racial inequality in education. They demand racism and gender-based harassment training for the district’s staff, aiming for long-lasting change.
Teacher Diversity in the U.S. (2022)
Black Teachers
Black Students
A 2022 report by the National Education Association found that only 7% of teachers in the United States are Black, compared to 15% of students.
Source: National Education Association
Training suggests fixing issues requires more than simply punishing wrongdoers. It involves changing how institutions function and educating everyone in the school community.
The Importance of the Lawsuit
The Hodges’ legal action severely criticizes the education system for failing to treat all students equally. It stresses that schools need to move beyond token gestures and actively eliminate racist practices.
Furthermore, this case shows how legal action can drive change when schools ignore internal complaints. Lawsuits enforce accountability and demand immediate address of racism.
FAQ
Q: What prompted the Hodge family to file a lawsuit?
A: The Hodge family filed a lawsuit against the West Ada School District due to ongoing racial harassment their daughters faced at Eagle High School, highlighting systemic racism in education.
Q: What incidents did the Hodge sisters experience at school?
A: The sisters suffered from various forms of racial harassment, including a false accusation against A.H. by a teacher and the repeated use of racial slurs in the classroom, fostering a hostile environment.
Q: How did the school administration respond to the complaints?
A: The school’s administration showed indifference, as the sisters were advised by a school resource officer to “just ignore” the harassment, despite the administrators being aware of the incidents.
Q: What are the broader implications of this case?
A: The Hodge family’s lawsuit highlights systemic issues and demands for racial and gender-based harassment training to promote cultural change within the school system and combat discrimination.
Q: What significance does the lawsuit hold for the education system?
A: The lawsuit serves as a critical call to action, urging schools to address systemic racism actively and highlighting legal action as a necessary tool for accountability and change.
Q: What can the community do in response to this issue?
A: The community can support efforts against systemic racism in education by amplifying voices that challenge discrimination and advocating for reforms that ensure equal treatment for all students.
ABOUT THE AUTHOR
Darius Spearman is a professor of Black Studies at San Diego City College, where he has been teaching since 2007. He is the author of several books, including Between The Color Lines: A History of African Americans on the California Frontier Through 1890. You can visit Darius online at africanelements.org.
