Listen to this article
Download AudioShiloh Community Struggles with Flooding Due to Highway Expansion Issues
By Darius Spearman (africanelements)
Support African Elements at patreon.com/africanelements and hear recent news in a single playlist. Additionally, you can gain early access to ad-free video content.
| KEY TAKEAWAYS |
|---|
| The expansion of U.S. Highway 84 in 2018 led to extensive flooding in Shiloh. |
| Residents accuse ALDOT of intentionally designing the highway drainage to flood their community. |
| Shiloh residents have filed a civil rights complaint alleging environmental racism. |
| A recent settlement requires ALDOT to construct a drainage system, but compensation for past damages is not guaranteed. |
| The flooding has severely damaged homes and contributed to the loss of generational wealth in Shiloh. |
| Experts stress the need for systemic change to address environmental justice issues faced by marginalized communities. |
The Devastating Impact of Highway 84 Expansion on Shiloh
In 2018, the expansion of U.S. Highway 84 in Alabama severely impacted the Black community of Shiloh. Widening the road from two to four lanes led to major flooding, affecting their homes and jobs. This problem has led to accusations of environmental racism against the Alabama Department of Transportation (ALDOT) as Shiloh struggles for fair treatment.
The flooding has turned Shiloh into a place of constant water damage, septic issues, and pests like snakes and rats. Houses are cracking and sinking from the constant water. Families lose many years of savings as property values drop and insurance costs go up. An engineering report showed that the water from the highway construction directly caused cracks in a resident’s brick house.
Allegations of Systemic Racism in Highway Design
Shiloh’s residents assert that ALDOT purposely designed the highway drainage to bring water to their community. All runoff goes near Shiloh’s homes, while white-owned farms nearby stay dry. This unfair impact has not escaped experts’ notice.
Coffee County Demographics
Dr. Robert Bullard, recognized as a key figure in environmental justice, stressed that Shiloh’s Black community bears an unfair burden. He argues a fair solution must address the root inequalities behind this situation.
The Battle for Justice and Compensation
Faced with massive damage, Shiloh’s residents took action. In 2022, they filed a civil rights complaint with the federal government, citing racial discrimination. This led to a settlement requiring a drainage system to fix the flooding. However, this solution falls short as it doesn’t cover the losses people have already suffered.
Residents are pushing for funds to fix or move from damaged homes but fear backlash. The state’s previous help attempts were weak. ALDOT paid three residents $5,000 or less but attached legal restrictions to stop them from suing. This tactic shows a troubling focus on legal safety rather than citizen welfare.
Environmental Justice and the Fight Against Systemic Racism
Shiloh’s situation is not unique but a clear example of the environmental injustices minority communities face. It stresses the urgent need to challenge systemic racial oppression in infrastructure and environmental policies.
Shiloh Flooding Timeline
Environmental justice ensures no group should face more environmental problems due to race or income. However, projects like Highway 84’s expansion often disregard this principle, overlooking the needs of Black and brown neighborhoods.
Understanding Environmental Racism and Systemic Inequalities
To grasp Shiloh’s plight, we must understand environmental racism and systemic inequalities. Environmental racism means that communities of color face more environmental hazards than others. This occurs when policies and practices expose these communities to pollution and hazards while others are protected (Wikipedia).
What Is Environmental Racism?
Environmental Racism: A form of discrimination where communities of color are burdened with disproportionate exposure to environmental hazards. This includes toxic waste sites, pollution, and other environmental dangers, often due to deliberate policies and practices (Augusta University).
These systemic inequalities are not random. They result from policies that place hazardous facilities near marginalized communities. Often, people of color lack political power and resources to resist these decisions (Talkspace). As a result, they face greater health risks and environmental dangers.
Dr. Robert Bullard and the Environmental Justice Movement
Dr. Robert Bullard, known as the “father of environmental justice,” has shed light on these issues for decades. He highlights how environmental policies often harm communities of color more than others (Wikipedia). His work shows that many hazardous waste sites and polluting industries are located near Black neighborhoods.
Dr. Bullard’s research has helped communities understand and fight against environmental injustices. The environmental justice movement, which he helped to shape, demands fair treatment for all people. It insists that everyone has the right to a clean and healthy environment (Medical News Today).
The Need for Rigorous Impact Analysis and Better Drainage Systems
The situation in Shiloh shows why we need thorough environmental impact assessments. These assessments evaluate how projects will affect the environment and people’s health. They help prevent harm by identifying risks before construction starts (World Economic Forum).
In Shiloh, the highway expansion lacked proper consideration of drainage impacts. The new drains directed water into the community, causing flooding. This design flaw reflects systemic issues in infrastructure planning. Adequate drainage systems are essential to protect communities from such disasters (Augusta University).
Pursuing Reparative Justice and Future Goals
Shiloh’s residents are not just seeking to stop the flooding; they are demanding reparative justice. This means compensating them for the losses they have suffered. It also involves restoring their community and preventing future injustices (World Economic Forum).
Filing a civil rights complaint was a crucial step. It alleged that the state violated their rights by causing disproportionate harm to a Black community. Such complaints can lead to investigations and require agencies to change their practices (Medical News Today).
Moving forward, the community aims to secure full compensation and ensure that no other community faces similar harm. Their struggle highlights the need for accountability and equitable policies. Only then can we prevent environmental racism and build healthier communities for all.
Statistics reveal that communities of color face higher risks of environmental hazards. For instance, pollution exposure is 54% greater for Black people compared to the overall population (Medical News Today). These numbers underscore the urgency of addressing environmental racism nationwide.
Challenging the Status Quo
Shiloh’s challenges show that fixing current systems is not enough. We must change and remove the systems allowing such unfairness. This includes:
- Empowering marginalized groups to influence decisions about their environment and health.
- Using detailed environmental assessments that consider racial equity.
- Holding authorities accountable with strong legal and financial penalties for environmental racism.
- Focusing on reparations for communities harmed by years of environmental neglect.
The Road Ahead for Shiloh and Beyond
Although the settlement is a start for Shiloh, true justice remains distant. Residents still seek full compensation and a plan to rebuild their community. Their fight is a call to action for environmental justice advocates everywhere.
As we face the deep roots of racism in America, Shiloh’s story reminds us that environmental justice is tied to racial justice. Addressing both can help create a society where all communities, regardless of race or economic background, thrive in safe, healthy places.
Shiloh’s flooding isn’t just a local problem. It’s a reminder of ongoing battles against environmental racism across the country. We must speak up, demand responsibility, and work hard for a fairer and more equal future.
FAQ
Q: What caused the flooding in Shiloh, Alabama?
A: The flooding was caused by the expansion of U.S. Highway 84, which resulted in a highway drainage system that allegedly floods the predominantly Black community of Shiloh while protecting nearby white-owned farmland.
Q: What are the accusations against the Alabama Department of Transportation (ALDOT)?
A: Residents accuse ALDOT of environmental racism, claiming the highway was designed to flood their community intentionally, resulting in severe property damage and a decline in property values.
Q: What actions have Shiloh residents taken in response to the flooding?
A: In 2022, residents filed a civil rights complaint with the federal government alleging unfair treatment based on race, leading to a settlement that includes plans for a new drainage system.
Q: Are residents receiving compensation for their losses?
A: While a settlement has been reached, it does not guarantee compensation for the losses already incurred by residents, many of whom are seeking a fund to help with relocation or repairs.
Q: How does this situation reflect broader issues of environmental justice?
A: The case exemplifies systemic racism in infrastructure planning and highlights the urgent need for environmental justice, ensuring no community disproportionately bears environmental burdens due to race or socioeconomic status.
ABOUT THE AUTHOR
Darius Spearman is a professor of Black Studies at San Diego City College, where he has been teaching since 2007. He is the author of several books, including Between The Color Lines: A History of African Americans on the California Frontier Through 1890. You can visit Darius online at africanelements.org.
