Listen to this article
Download AudioBlack Texas Woman Detained: A Racial Profiling Case Analysis
Racial profiling shadows Black lives in Texas.
By Darius Spearman (africanelements)
Support African Elements at patreon.com/africanelements and hear recent news in a single playlist. Additionally, you can gain early access to ad-free video content.
Detained for Walking While Black Incidents
Another day, another story that makes you shake your head. A pregnant Black woman found herself stopped and ticketed by police in Texas. Her alleged crime? Walking on the “wrong side” of the road. Meanwhile, her white husband, walking right there with her, faced no issues from the officers (Atlanta Black Star). This stark difference in treatment highlights a painful reality many Black folks know too well.
The husband captured the incident on video, his voice laced with disbelief, calling the situation “ridiculous” (Atlanta Black Star). He explicitly pointed out the racial disparity before sharing the footage online. Subsequently, the video circulated on Instagram, showing the woman detained in an area identified as The Grove (judah_unapologetic Instagram). Hashtags like #WALKINGWHILEBLACK quickly followed, linking this incident to a broader pattern of racial profiling experienced during everyday activities.
Texas Walking Incident: A Tale of Two Pedestrians
Troubling Patterns: Texas Racial Profiling Cases
This isn’t an isolated event in Texas. History shows a pattern where race seems to play a role in police interactions. For instance, back in 2019, Clarence Evans, a Black man in Houston, faced a terrifying mistaken identity situation. A white deputy attempted to arrest him based on a warrant for someone else, an incident widely seen as racial profiling (ABC News). Despite the clear error, the Harris County Constable defended the deputy’s actions.
Furthermore, Texas has seen other forms of race-based targeting. In 2022, a Plano woman was arrested after a video captured her racist, violent rant against South Asian women (The Dallas Morning News). This incident was classified as a hate crime. These prior cases, alongside the recent detention of the pregnant Black woman, suggest a persistent issue with racial bias in how laws are enforced and how people of color are treated by authorities within the state. Together, they paint a picture not of isolated incidents, but of repetitive patterns validating claims of systemic issues.
Understanding Racial Profiling
- Using race to justify stops for minor violations (Wikipedia).
- Searching pedestrians without cause, often based on location and appearance (ACLU).
- Disproportionate stops of Black drivers (“Driving While Black”) or pedestrians (“Walking While Black”) (Wikipedia, Study.com).
- Targeting specific ethnic groups, historically and in modern contexts (Wikipedia).
Police Detentions and Racial Disparities: A Systemic Issue
The detention of the pregnant Black woman while her white husband was ignored isn’t just about one officer’s potential bias. It points to a deeper problem: systemic bias. This type of bias isn’t always about individual prejudice; instead, it’s woven into the fabric of institutions (PMC). Historical practices like segregation and negative cultural narratives create environments where discriminatory actions can occur and even seem normal.
Think about how certain neighborhoods, often communities of color facing concentrated disadvantage, experience heavier policing (PMC). Minor infractions, like the Texas pedestrian law violation, are selectively enforced. These stops often serve as pretexts for questioning, searching, or detaining individuals based on race (Wikipedia). The quick issuance of a ticket in the Texas incident, without apparent de-escalation, suggests a focus on enforcement over community safety, reflecting how these systemic biases play out on the ground (ACLU). Consequently, the system perpetuates cycles of inequality and mistrust between law enforcement and Black communities.
Understanding Systemic Bias
- Arises from historical legacies like segregation and discriminatory laws (PMC – Systemic Approach).
- Reinforced by cultural narratives and power imbalances (PMC – Systemic Approach).
- Manifests in practices like racial profiling and selective law enforcement (Wikipedia).
- Contributes to concentrated disadvantage in specific communities (PMC – Racial Discrimination).
- Creates self-perpetuating cycles of inequality without explicit discriminatory intent in every action.
Viral Videos and the Quest for Accountability
The video of the Texas incident quickly gained attention online, amplified by platforms like Instagram and reported by outlets such as Atlanta Black Star (Atlanta Black Star Instagram). This follows a now-familiar pattern where viral videos serve as crucial evidence, bringing instances of potential bias and misconduct out of the shadows. Much like the documentation of police brutality, these videos challenge official narratives and expose systemic issues (Study.com).
These recordings empower communities by providing a tool for accountability. They spark public conversation and put pressure on authorities to respond. However, the response is often slow or non-existent. In the Texas case, there has been no official statement from law enforcement, nor has any bodycam footage been released (Atlanta Black Star). This lack of transparency fuels distrust. Policies regarding bodycam footage release vary widely, and delays or refusals often hinder efforts to hold officers accountable, reflecting systemic failures (ACLU). Therefore, while viral videos are powerful, they are just one step in the long fight for systemic change and justice.
ABOUT THE AUTHOR
Darius Spearman is a professor of Black Studies at San Diego City College, where he has been teaching since 2007. He is the author of several books, including Between The Color Lines: A History of African Americans on the California Frontier Through 1890. You can visit Darius online at africanelements.org.
