Listen to this article
Download AudioCornell Deportation: Pro-Palestinian Protests
By Darius Spearman (africanelements)
Support African Elements at patreon.com/africanelements and hear recent news in a single playlist. Additionally, you can gain early access to ad-free video content.
Momodou Taal’s Deportation Threat
Imagine being a college student, fighting for what you believe in, and suddenly facing deportation. That’s the reality for Momodou Taal, a student at Cornell University. Federal authorities are trying to detain Taal, seemingly because of his involvement in pro-Palestinian protests and his challenge to policies from the Trump administration (Defend Momodou Taal | UE). It feels like a punch to the gut, especially when you consider the long history of silencing Black voices and activism.
Taal received a formal demand to surrender to ICE on March 22. The demand came shortly after he filed a lawsuit against Trump’s executive orders, which many see as targeting pro-Palestinian activists (A Cornell student suing the Trump administration …). It’s hard not to connect the dots here. Moreover, the Trump administration revoked Taal’s student visa under Executive Order 14188. This order equates criticism of Israel with antisemitism (Lawyers for Momodou Taal denounce Trump administration’s …). Legal filings claim his visa was canceled because of “disruptive protests” and creating a “hostile environment for Jewish students”(Columbia, Cornell students dodge ICE …).
The Broader Pattern of Academic Suppression
This isn’t just about one student; it appears to be part of a bigger problem. Taal’s case highlights a disturbing trend of suppressing free speech, especially when it comes to pro-Palestinian activism in academia. It’s a pattern that echoes the struggles of Black activists throughout history who were targeted for speaking out against injustice.
Taal, along with co-plaintiffs like Cornell professor Mũkoma Wa Ngũgĩ, argue that Trump’s executive orders violate the First and Fifth Amendments. Their main argument is that these orders weaponize immigration enforcement to punish those who disagree with certain policies (Lawyers for Momodou Taal denounce …), (Defend Momodou Taal | UE). Besides, the fact that ICE is using “open-source information,” like pro-Israel websites, to justify targeting activists is alarming. Consequently, this suggests a systematic surveillance of campus protests (Columbia, Cornell students dodge ICE …).
Cornell’s Role in Momodou’s Case
It’s disappointing to see how Cornell University’s administration may have played a part in making Taal more vulnerable to deportation. His story brings up painful memories. It echoes the past when institutions often sided against Black students and activists.
Cornell terminated and suspended Taal in September 2023 for his activism, even though there was no proof he did anything wrong. His charges were never properly investigated. Yet, the university’s actions put his visa status at risk (Defend Momodou Taal | UE), (A Cornell student suing the Trump administration …). Furthermore, Cornell’s “interim disciplinary measures” have been called out as unfair tools used to silence marginalized workers (Defend Momodou Taal | UE).
Cornell’s Actions Against Taal
Fighting Back: Legal Action and Union Support
Thankfully, Taal is not alone in this fight. His legal team and various labor unions are stepping up to stop his deportation and challenge the constitutionality of these executive orders. The support network is like a lifeline, showing the power of the community in standing up against injustice.
Over a dozen locals of the UE union have signed a statement condemning ICE’s actions and demanding better protections for graduate workers (Defend Momodou Taal | UE). Subsequently, Taal’s attorneys filed an emergency motion for a temporary restraining order. Someone saw unknown law enforcement agents near Taal’s home (Taal Told to Surrender Himself to ICE Custody).
A Coordinated Crackdown on Pro-Palestinian Activism
Taal’s situation isn’t unique. This trend of targeting people is happening across the United States. It’s chilling to see similar cases emerge, suggesting a coordinated effort to crack down on pro-Palestinian activists under Trump’s policies.
Other students, like Columbia student Mahmoud Khalil and Georgetown researcher Badar Khan Suri, also face deportation. Someone linked them to “Hamas propaganda” or undisclosed affiliations (Columbia, Cornell students dodge ICE …). Furthermore, officials invoked the Alien Enemies Act of 1798. They could deport many without due process (Lawyers for Momodou Taal denounce …). This raises significant concerns about potential overreach.
Trump’s Antisemitism Executive Orders
Executive Order 14188 is central to the Trump administration’s actions.
This seems to be the foundation of the actions being taken against people voicing their opinions.
As people of African descent, we must watch these developments closely.
EO 14188 gives federal agencies the power to target noncitizens based on their political speech, especially if they criticize Israeli policies. The order allows for visa revocation by having agencies review “open-source information” (e.g., media reports of protests). It also encourages collaboration with universities to monitor student activity (Lawyers for Momodou Taal denounce Trump administration’s…). The order’s definition of “anti-Semitic harassment” is very broad. This has made it easier to target pro-Palestinian activism by labeling it as creating “hostile environments” for Jewish students (Lawyers for Momodou Taal denounce Trump administration’s…), (EO 14188 § 3(e) directs agencies to report on recommendations…).
Executive Order 14188 Impact
Impacts & The First/Fifth Amendment Rights
The actions against Taal and others are seen as violating the First and Fifth Amendments. From an African-American perspective, this is yet another way authorities try to stifle dissent. This seems to be a violation of free speech rights and due process.
Taal’s lawyers argue that the government used EO 14188 to remove him precisely because of his pro-Palestinian activism. It was not because of any objectively anti-Semitic actions (Lawyers for Momodou Taal denounce Trump administration’s…). The order includes actions such as “patterns of activity”, which is a broad term. Furthermore, the timing of Taal’s visa revocation is suspicious, as it closely followed his lawsuit filing. Therefore, it is something that undermines his access to the courts. Additionally, Momodou’s legal team points out that ICE seemed to ignore the usual processes. For instance, they finalized his visa revocation in one day without giving a solid reason (Lawyers for Momodou Taal denounce Trump administration’s…).
What Happens Next in This Deportation Case
The legal fight is ongoing. Taal’s team is pushing for an emergency injunction to stop his deportation while the courts consider whether his constitutional rights have been violated (Lawyers for Momodou Taal denounce Trump administration’s…). It’s a crucial moment, one that will hopefully set a precedent for protecting free speech and due process, not just for students but for everyone.
This case is a stark reminder of the constant battle for justice and equality. From the struggles of the Civil Rights Movement to today’s fights against systemic oppression, the fight for free speech and fair treatment remains a constant. It’s a struggle that requires us to stay informed, stay vigilant, and remain united in demanding a better future for all.
ABOUT THE AUTHOR
Darius Spearman has been a professor of Black Studies at San Diego City College since 2007. He is the author of several books, including Between The Color Lines: A History of African Americans on the California Frontier Through 1890. You can visit Darius online at africanelements.org.
