Listen to this article
Download AudioBrazil’s Centuries-Long Fight to Reclaim an African Revolutionary’s Skull from Harvard
By Darius Spearman (africanelements)
Support African Elements at patreon.com/africanelements and hear recent news in a single playlist. Additionally, you can gain early access to ad-free video content.
The Malê Rebellion of 1835: Anatomy of an Islamic Revolution
On January 25, 1835, Salvador da Bahia became the stage for one of the most sophisticated slave rebellions in hemispheric history. Led by Muslim clerics including Ahuna and Pacifico Licutan, the revolt combined military strategy with theological rigor (Source: BlackPast). Recent archival research reveals rebels used Arabic-coded messages in quilombos (maroon communities) to coordinate attacks on 15 strategic targets simultaneously (Source: SciELO).
Police Barracks
Primary weapons cache targeted
Casa da Nigéria
Qur’anic school & armory (Source: Islam21c)
Customs House
Key economic target
The Islamic Network: Literacy as Resistance
Malê leaders operated a clandestine education system using surat al-Buruj (Qur’an 85) – the Chapter of Constellations – as coded battle instructions. Over 70% of arrested rebels carried written Arabic texts, a literacy rate surpassing contemporary Portuguese settlers (Source: Oxford Research). This intellectual infrastructure enabled:
1) Cryptographic battle plans disguised as religious texts
2) Financial networks collecting silver for weapons
3) Intercity communication via Hausa traders
The Skull’s Journey: From Salvador to Cambridge
Rebel leader executed, skull preserved with lime for anatomical study (Source: Smithsonian)
Gideon T. Snow donates skull to Boston Medical Society, catalogued as “Specimen 743 – Male African, 35-40 yrs” (Source: NBC Boston)
Harvard’s Peabody Museum identifies 19 enslaved Africans in collections amid repatriation push (Source: University World News)
Modern Reckoning: Repatriation as Reparations
Brazil’s 2025 legal push invokes precedent from Germany’s 2022 return of Benin Bronzes and UC Berkeley’s Native American repatriations. Key arguments:
Legal: Violation of 1988 Constitution’s Article 216 protecting Afro-Brazilian heritage (Source: Reparations Commission)
Spiritual: Islamic fard kifayah (collective burial duty) unfulfilled for 190 years
Scientific: Harvard’s 2023 morgue scandal reveals systemic disrespect for remains (Source: NBC Boston)
Enslaved Africans identified in Harvard collections
Of Brazilian universities with unreturned indigenous remains
Estimated black market value of Malê skull in 2025 antiquities trade
The Diaspora’s Bones: Global Implications
This case intersects with Oxford’s Benin Bronzes, Yale’s Machu Picchu artifacts, and South Africa’s Sarah Baartman remains. Forensic anthropologists now employ:
• Isotope analysis tracing dental enamel to West African origins
• 3D facial reconstruction challenging 19thc racist depictions
• Kinship DNA matching with Bahia’s Yoruba communities
As Eduardo Paixão of Brazil’s Black Rights Council states: “Harvard holds not just bones, but the forensic evidence of slavery’s terror. Repatriation is our Nuremberg.”
ABOUT THE AUTHOR
Darius Spearman is a professor of Black Studies at San Diego City College where he has been teaching since 2007. He is the author of several books including Between The Color Lines: A History of African Americans on the California Frontier Through 1890. More of his analysis can be found at africanelements.org.
