Bridging the Divide: Diversifying Special Education
By Darius Spearman (africanelements)
Support African Elements at patreon.com/africanelements and hear recent news in a single playlist. Additionally, you can gain early access to ad-free video content.
The Stark Reality of Teacher Diversity in Special Education
The landscape of education in the United States reveals a striking demographic imbalance. The special education teacher workforce, which serves a diverse student population, remains overwhelmingly white. This situation presents a significant challenge for our schools and, more importantly, for our children. In 2012, approximately 80 percent of United States public school teachers, including those in special education, were white (theconversation.com). Less than 20 percent were teachers of color.
This demographic reality stands in stark contrast to the student population. In that same year, students of color constituted 47 percent of those diagnosed with disabilities (theconversation.com). The term “teachers of color” generally refers to educators who identify as Black, Hispanic, Asian, or other non-White racial or ethnic groups (journals.sagepub.com). Among these groups, Black and Hispanic teachers make up the majority of teachers of color in the workforce (journals.sagepub.com). A smaller proportion of Hispanic special education teachers exists compared to Hispanic general education teachers (journals.sagepub.com).
The disparity has only grown wider over time. From 2012 to 2021, the proportion of special education teachers of color remained largely static, moving from 16.5 percent to 17.1 percent (theconversation.com). Meanwhile, the share of students with disabilities who are students of color increased from 47.3 percent to 53.9 percent during the same period (theconversation.com). This means the special education teacher workforce is becoming less representative of the student population it serves. To achieve a truly representative special education teacher workforce, the number of special education teachers of color would need to triple (theconversation.com).
This demographic mismatch extends beyond special education into the broader K-12 public school system. While teachers of color represent 21 percent of public school educators, students of color account for more than 52 percent of public school students (theconversation.com). In the 1999–2000 school year, 38 percent of public school students identified as people of color, compared with just 16 percent of teachers (rand.org). By 2017–18, over half of students were people of color, but the share of teachers of color remained low at 21 percent (rand.org). Furthermore, the share of Native American and Black teachers in the workforce is declining, not growing like the populations of Latinx and Asian American teachers (learningpolicyinstitute.org).
Special Education Demographics: A Growing Disparity
Why Representation Matters: Benefits for All Students
The presence of teachers of color provides significant benefits to all students, especially students of color. Research clearly shows that teachers of color are, on average, more effective than white teachers in providing positive educational experiences and outcomes for students of color (theconversation.com). This includes students of color with disabilities. The effectiveness of teachers is likely measured through a combination of academic outcomes, social-emotional development, and the positive impact of representation on students (rand.org).
Consider the profound impact on Black male students. One study found that low-income Black male students who had one Black teacher in third, fourth, or fifth grade were 39 percent less likely to drop out of high school (theconversation.com). Furthermore, they were 29 percent more likely to enroll in college (theconversation.com). Students of color benefit from having access to teachers who look like them, which can improve their test scores, graduation rates, and college-going rates (rand.org). Importantly, these positive effects come with no adverse effects on white students (rand.org). In fact, teachers of color are just as effective as white teachers, and sometimes more effective, in teaching white students (theconversation.com).
The term “students diagnosed with disabilities” encompasses a wide range of conditions that qualify students for special education services under federal law. Research indicates that while students of color are often overrepresented in special education, some studies suggest they may be underrepresented when controlling for background differences (journals.sagepub.com). This raises concerns about potential under-identification for services. The lack of teachers who understand the cultural backgrounds and behaviors of students has been cited as a potential source of the overidentification of students of color in special education (journals.sagepub.com). Federal data has shown past and current overrepresentation of students of color in special education (journals.sagepub.com). However, studies based on richer student-level data have revealed that students of color are underrepresented relative to White peers in special education when controlling for student background differences (journals.sagepub.com). This underrepresentation raises the concern that students of color, when statistically similar to White students, are overlooked for special education services (journals.sagepub.com).
K-12 Public School Demographics: A Broad Mismatch
Pathways to Progress: Initiatives and Institutions
Despite the challenges, various initiatives and institutions are actively working to increase the diversity of the teacher workforce. Historically Black Colleges and Universities (HBCUs), Hispanic-Serving Institutions (HSIs), and other Minority-Serving Institutions (MSIs) play a vital role (theconversation.com). These institutions prepare a substantial number of new teachers of color annually (tandfonline.com). They are incubators for diverse talent, fostering environments where future educators of color can thrive.
Local initiatives also contribute significantly to this effort. “Grow Your Own” (GYO) programs, for example, are designed to recruit and train individuals from within a community, often paraprofessionals or high school students, to become certified teachers (theconversation.com). These programs are particularly effective in areas with high needs, such as special education. Teacher residency programs also help retain teachers of color (theconversation.com). Additionally, scholarships and loan forgiveness programs offer crucial financial support to all teachers, including teachers of color (theconversation.com).
However, the United States educator workforce faces broad challenges that complicate these diversification efforts. There is a declining interest in the teaching profession overall (theconversation.com). This is coupled with declining enrollment in teacher preparation programs (theconversation.com). People of color face systemic barriers to becoming and remaining teachers at multiple points throughout their careers (rand.org). For example, people of color are more likely than their white peers to incur student debt (rand.org). They might also lack access to teacher role models who share their lived experiences (rand.org). Furthermore, people of color often experience bias during the hiring process (rand.org). Once they become teachers, they are more likely to work in challenging environments (rand.org). These systemic issues highlight the need for comprehensive strategies to support and retain culturally and linguistically diverse teachers in special education (journals.sagepub.com).
The Transformative Impact of Black Teachers on Black Male Students
The Roadblocks: Anti-DEI Movement and Systemic Barriers
While efforts to diversify the teacher workforce are underway, recent policy changes pose a significant threat. The Trump administration’s push to end diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI) programs has led to cuts in grant funding (theconversation.com). These programs were specifically designed to develop a diverse educator workforce. Such actions undermine the progress made and exacerbate existing challenges.
Millions of dollars dedicated to training teachers for underfunded, high-poverty schools have been cut (theconversation.com). Furthermore, there are threats of additional funding cuts for universities engaged in equity-based work (theconversation.com). These federal actions make the teacher workforce less equipped to address critical issues facing United States schools. These issues include declining interest in the teaching profession and persistent racial disparities in student outcomes (theconversation.com).
The persistent gap between the increasing diversity of the student population and the static or declining diversity among special education teachers is attributed to systemic barriers. These barriers affect people of color throughout their careers (rand.org). Financial challenges, such as higher student debt, are a significant hurdle (rand.org). A lack of role models who share similar lived experiences also impacts recruitment (rand.org). Bias in hiring practices and challenging work environments further contribute to the retention problem (rand.org). Given the strong evidence of the benefits of teachers of color and the national trends, federal and state investments should prioritize supporting prospective teachers of color (theconversation.com). This investment is crucial for ensuring that all students, especially students of color with disabilities, receive the quality education they deserve.
ABOUT THE AUTHOR
Darius Spearman has been a professor of Black Studies at San Diego City College since 2007. He is the author of several books, including Between The Color Lines: A History of African Americans on the California Frontier Through 1890. You can visit Darius online at africanelements.org.
