Rolin Hill’s Death Highlights Systemic Issues in Law Enforcement

By Darius Spearman (africanelements)

Support African Elements at patreon.com/africanelements and hear recent news in a single playlist. Additionally, you can gain early access to ad-free video content.

KEY TAKEAWAYS
Rolin Hill died after being restrained, ruled a homicide by authorities.
He suffered a medical emergency during the booking process.
Five deputies involved in Hill’s booking have been terminated from duty.
Investigations by state police and local authorities are ongoing.
Hill’s death reflects systemic issues in law enforcement practices.
His family advocates for mental health support in law enforcement contexts.

Rolin Hill Death: A Tragic Example of Systemic Racism in Law Enforcement

The death of Rolin Hill, a 34-year-old Black man, at the hands of Virginia Beach Correctional Center deputies has again thrust the issue of racism in law enforcement into the national spotlight. Hill’s tragic demise highlights the urgent need for accountability and reform within the criminal justice system.

Understanding Systemic Racism in Law Enforcement

To grasp the full impact of Hill’s death, it’s vital to understand systemic racism within law enforcement. Systemic racism refers to ingrained policies and practices that result in unequal outcomes for different racial groups. These inequities are not always the result of overt prejudice but are embedded in the structures of institutions.

Understanding Systemic Racism in Law Enforcement

To grasp the full impact of Hill’s death, it’s vital to understand systemic racism within law enforcement. Systemic racism refers to ingrained policies and practices that result in unequal outcomes for different racial groups. These inequities are not always the result of overt prejudice but are embedded in the structures of institutions.

Historically, law enforcement in the United States has been linked to controlling and oppressing Black communities. From slave patrols to Jim Crow laws, policing has often been a tool to enforce racial hierarchies. This legacy continues today, as seen in cases like Hill’s.

Over-Policing and Quality of Life Offenses

Over-policing refers to excessive surveillance and enforcement in certain communities, particularly those of color. Minor infractions, often termed “quality of life” offenses, become gateways for police interactions that can escalate dangerously. Trespassing and disorderly conduct, the charges against Hill, are examples of such offenses.

These minor charges disproportionately affect Black individuals, leading to higher arrest rates and increased exposure to potential violence. Consequently, Black communities face a cycle of criminalization that perpetuates distrust and fear of law enforcement.

The Intersection of Mental Health and Race

Mental health plays a significant role in interactions with law enforcement. Individuals experiencing a mental health crisis may not respond to commands in expected ways, which can be misinterpreted as non-compliance or aggression. For Black individuals, systemic racism adds another layer of complexity to these encounters.

Racial disparities in access to mental health care mean that Black individuals are less likely to receive proper treatment. Additionally, the stress of experiencing racism can contribute to mental health challenges. Therefore, when law enforcement responds to situations involving mental health without proper training, the outcomes can be tragic.

A Call for Accountability and Community-Based Alternatives

Accountability goes beyond firing individual officers; it requires systemic change. The lack of charges against the deputies involved in Hill’s death highlights the challenges in holding law enforcement accountable. Communities are calling for alternatives that focus on safety and wellness rather than punishment.

Community-based programs can address issues like mental health crises without involving police. Investing in such alternatives can reduce reliance on law enforcement and prevent unnecessary confrontations (Community-Based Alternatives to Policing). Transitioning to these models requires commitment from policymakers and support from the public.

Virginia Beach Jail Incident: A Lethal Encounter

On June 4, 2024, Rolin Hill was in police custody for trespassing and disorderly conduct. This routine booking at the Virginia Beach Correctional Center quickly spiraled into a fatal confrontation. During the process, Hill allegedly became combative, prompting deputies to restrain him. Sadly, their actions proved deadly.

Shortly after being subdued, Hill suffered a medical emergency and was quickly transferred to a local hospital. Six days later, on June 10, 2024, Hill succumbed to his injuries. The Office of the Chief Medical Examiner later ruled his death a homicide, citing “positional and mechanical asphyxia due to restraint with neck and torso compression.”

This grim sequence shows the potentially lethal consequences of excessive force and improper restraint. It raises urgent questions about training and de-escalation methods at correctional facilities nationwide.

Deputies Fired After Inmate’s Death: A Step Towards Accountability

After Hill’s death and the investigation, the Virginia Beach Sheriff’s Office acted decisively. On October 18, 2024, five deputies involved in Hill’s booking were fired. This decision was based on updates from the ongoing Virginia State Police investigation.

While firing these deputies represents a step towards accountability, one must see it as insufficient. Terminating individual officers without major changes perpetuates a cycle of injustice affecting Black Americans.

Jail Restraint Homicide: A Systemic Problem

The situation surrounding Rolin Hill’s death is part of a larger pattern of violence against Black people in custody. Excessive force and lethal restraint have long been concerns in U.S. correctional facilities.

Hill’s death by “positional and mechanical asphyxia” is similar to other high-profile cases, such as George Floyd’s. These incidents underline the need for changes in restraint techniques and use-of-force policies.

Additionally, the initial charges against Hill raise questions about the policing of Black behavior. These minor offenses often serve as excuses for unjust policing, leading to deadly encounters.

Virginia Beach Sheriff’s Office Investigation: Transparency and Justice

The Virginia State Police and the Virginia Beach Commonwealth’s Attorney’s Office are investigating. So far, no arrests have been made, and no charges have been filed. The Virginia Beach NAACP calls for justice and transparency.

While necessary, these investigations often fall short of delivering real justice. The conflicts in law enforcement investigating itself and the historical lack of accountability create skepticism. True justice requires more than investigating this incident; it demands addressing racism in our criminal justice system.

The Role of Mental Health in Criminal Justice

After Hill’s death, his family asked for donations to mental health foundations in his honor. This request underscores another critical issue — the intersection of mental health and criminal justice.

Too often, people experiencing mental health crises clash with law enforcement ill-prepared for such situations. The criminalization of mental illness affects Black Americans, who face barriers to mental health care access.

Conclusion: Beyond Reform – Dismantling Systemic Racism

Rolin Hill’s death represents a failure of individual deputies and a system steeped in racial bias and violence. While firing the deputies and continuing investigations are steps, they don’t address the root causes.

True justice for Rolin Hill and others lost to police violence requires rethinking public safety and criminal justice. This means more than police reform—it involves investing in community-based alternatives and mental health services and addressing socioeconomic factors linked to over-policing.

The fight for justice for Rolin Hill opposes systemic racism in America. It’s a call for action for everyone who believes in equality to demand not just accountability in individual acts but a transformation of a flawed system.

FAQ

Q: Who was Rolin Hill?
A: Rolin Hill was a 34-year-old Black man who died while in the custody of the Virginia Beach Correctional Center deputies under circumstances that have raised concerns about systemic racism and police accountability.

Q: What events led to Rolin Hill’s death?
A: Hill was initially taken into custody on charges of trespassing, resisting arrest, and disorderly conduct. During the booking process, he became uncooperative, leading to deputies restraining him, which ultimately resulted in a medical emergency and his death six days later.

Q: What was the cause of Rolin Hill’s death?
A: The Office of the Chief Medical Examiner ruled Hill’s death a homicide, attributing it to “positional and mechanical asphyxia due to restraint with neck and torso compression.”

Q: What action was taken against the deputies involved?
A: On October 18, 2024, five deputies involved in Hill’s booking were terminated from their positions as a result of the ongoing investigation by the Virginia State Police.

Q: How does Hill’s case relate to systemic issues in law enforcement?
A: Hill’s death highlights broader patterns of violence against Black individuals in custody and raises urgent questions about the use of excessive force, restraint techniques, and the criminalization of Black behaviors within the justice system.

Q: What are the larger implications of Hill’s death?
A: It underscores the urgent need for systemic reform in law enforcement, including mental health interventions and a reevaluation of how policing impacts Black communities.

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Darius Spearman is a professor of Black Studies at San Diego City College, where he has been teaching since 2007. He is the author of several books, including Between The Color Lines: A History of African Americans on the California Frontier Through 1890. You can visit Darius online at africanelements.org.