The Urgent Need to Address Air Pollution Impacting NYC’s Minority Subway Riders
By Darius Spearman (africanelements)
Support African Elements at patreon.com/africanelements and hear recent news in a single playlist. Additionally, you can gain early access to ad-free video content.

KEY TAKEAWAYS |
---|
New York City’s subway air quality is alarmingly toxic, especially underground. |
Subway riders, particularly Black and Hispanic communities, face disproportionate exposure to high pollution levels. |
Health risks of subway air include respiratory issues, heart disease, and even cancer. |
Particulate matter (PM2.5) is a significant pollutant, leading to various health complications. |
MTA has been criticized for inadequate responses to air quality concerns in the subway. |
Improving subway air quality may require significant investments and innovative solutions. |
Long commutes for minority riders worsen their exposure to hazardous subway air. |
The subway air pollution crisis highlights broader environmental and health justice issues. |
Action is needed to balance the environmental benefits of subways with the health needs of riders. |
Ongoing studies and research are essential to inform policy changes for better air quality. |
The Hidden Threat: Air Pollution’s Impact on Black and Hispanic Subway Riders in New York City
Unveiling the Toxic Air in NYC Subways
Alarming Levels of Air Pollution in Underground Transit
New York City’s subway system, a lifeline for millions, hides a silent danger. Recent studies show that subway riders breathe in toxic air far above safe levels. This issue hits Black and Hispanic riders the hardest (New York City subways expose commuters to toxic air).
The air in subway stations is not just dirty – it’s dangerous. On platforms, the air is ten times more polluted than what health experts say is safe. Inside trains, it’s seven times over the limit. Every day, about 5.5 million people breathe this toxic air (New York City subways expose commuters to toxic air).
What makes subway air so bad? It’s a mix of things:
- Train exhaust
- Dead rodents
- Poor air flow
- Dust kicked up by trains
The Disproportionate Impact on Minority Communities
The toxic air problem isn’t equal for everyone. Black and Hispanic workers face much worse air than others. They breathe in 35% more polluted air than Asian workers and 23% more than white workers (New York City subways expose commuters to toxic air).
Air Pollution Exposure by Demographics in New York City Subways
Source: New York City subways expose commuters to toxic airThis chart shows the relative exposure to polluted air for different demographic groups in New York City subways. Black and Hispanic workers are exposed to 35% and 23% more polluted air than Asian and white workers, respectively. The average subway platform has particulate pollution (PM 2.5) levels four times higher than the EPA’s 24-hour safety threshold. Daily, 5.5 million commuters are exposed to these conditions.
Why is this happening? It’s not just about race. It’s about where people live and work. Black and Hispanic New Yorkers often live farther from their jobs. This means longer rides and more time breathing bad air. They also switch trains more, spending extra time on polluted platforms (NYC subway riders exposed to toxic air: Study).
Air Pollution Levels in Subway Systems
Source: New York City subway riders are breathing in hazardous air, study findsThis chart compares air pollution levels in different parts of subway systems to WHO recommended limits. Subway platforms have PM 2.5 levels nine times above WHO limits, while trains have levels seven times the limit. Philadelphia’s subway systems show pollution levels about four times higher than above ground.
The air quality in some parts of the subway can be 15 times worse than what health experts recommend. This puts a huge health burden on communities already facing other challenges (NYC subway riders exposed to toxic air: Study).
Health Risks for Commuter Health in NYC
Short-Term and Long-Term Health Effects
Breathing subway air isn’t just unpleasant – it’s risky. In the short term, it can trigger asthma attacks and make breathing hard. But the long-term effects are even scarier. Years of exposure can lead to heart disease and cancer (New York City subways expose commuters to toxic air).
The main culprit is something called PM2.5. These are tiny particles that can get deep into your lungs and even your blood. They’re so small you can’t see them, but they can do a lot of damage (NYC Subway Riders Ingest ‘Exceptionally High’ Amounts of Air Pollution Every Day).
Here’s what PM2.5 can do to your body:
- Irritate your airways
- Make asthma worse
- Increase your risk of heart attacks
- Raise your chances of lung cancer
- Affect your mood and mental health
The Global Impact of Air Pollution
The subway air problem is part of a bigger issue. Air pollution is a global killer. In the last 40 years, it’s taken 135 million lives worldwide. That’s more than all the wars in that time combined (New York City subways expose commuters to toxic air).
Health Impacts of Air Pollution
Source: New York City subways expose commuters to toxic airThis chart shows the global deaths attributed to air pollution over the last four decades, totaling 135 million people. The visualization highlights the severe health impacts of air pollution, including asthma flare-ups, difficulty breathing, heart disease, and cancer. The climate crisis is linked to an increase in air pollution, exacerbating these health effects.
As our climate changes, air pollution gets worse. The two problems feed each other. Hotter weather can trap pollutants in the air. More pollution leads to more climate change. It’s a cycle that’s hard to break (New York City subways expose commuters to toxic air).
The subway air problem shows how environmental issues often hit vulnerable groups hardest. It’s not just about clean air – it’s about fairness and health justice.
Subway Particulate Matter Concerns
Understanding PM2.5 and Its Sources
PM2.5 is the main bad guy in subway air. These particles are tiny – about 30 times smaller than a human hair. They come from all sorts of places in the subway:
- Brake dust from trains
- Tiny metal bits from wheels and tracks
- Dust kicked up by trains and people
- Outdoor pollution that gets trapped underground
When trains pull into stations, they stir up all this dust. Riders then breathe it in. The more time you spend in the subway, the more of these particles you inhale (NYC subway riders exposed to toxic air: Study).
Comparing Subway Air to Outdoor Air
You might think that being underground protects you from air pollution. But it’s the opposite. Subway air is often much worse than the air above ground. In Philadelphia, for example, the air in subway stations was four times more polluted than street-level air (New York City subway riders are breathing in hazardous air, study finds).
New York’s subway air is even worse. On platforms, PM2.5 levels are nine times higher than what the World Health Organization says is safe. Inside trains, it’s seven times over the limit. That means every subway trip exposes you to a lot of harmful particles (New York City subway riders are breathing in hazardous air, study finds).
The Masoud Ghandehari Subway Study
Key Findings and Methodology
Dr. Masoud Ghandehari and his team at NYU did a big study on subway air. They used special equipment to measure air quality on platforms and in trains. What they found was shocking (NYC subway riders exposed to toxic air: Study).
Here are the main things they discovered:
- Subway platforms have PM2.5 levels four times higher than EPA safety limits
- Train cars have slightly better air, but still way over safe levels
- Black and Hispanic riders face much higher exposure due to longer commutes
- Poor ventilation in stations traps and recirculates pollutants
The study didn’t just look at air quality. It also checked who was breathing the worst air. By looking at commute patterns, they saw how some groups got hit harder than others (NYC subway riders exposed to toxic air: Study).
Implications for Public Health and Policy
This study is a wake-up call. It shows that millions of New Yorkers face health risks just by going to work. It also highlights how environmental problems often affect some groups more than others. This isn’t just about clean air – it’s about fairness (NYC Subway Riders Ingest ‘Exceptionally High’ Amounts of Air Pollution Every Day).
The findings put pressure on city officials to act. They need to find ways to clean up subway air and protect riders. This might mean better ventilation, cleaner trains, or new station designs. It also means looking at how transit planning affects different communities (NYC Subway Riders Ingest ‘Exceptionally High’ Amounts of Air Pollution Every Day).
Respiratory Issues in Subway Riders
Immediate Health Effects of Subway Air
Breathing subway air can make you feel bad right away. Some riders get headaches or feel dizzy. Others have trouble breathing or start coughing. These problems are worse for people who already have health issues like asthma (New York City subways expose commuters to toxic air).
The tiny particles in subway air can irritate your lungs and airways. This can lead to:
- Coughing and wheezing
- Shortness of breath
- Chest tightness
- Asthma attacks
- Eye and throat irritation
These effects might seem small, but they add up over time. Day after day of breathing bad air can wear down your body’s defenses (New York City subways expose commuters to toxic air).
Long-Term Consequences of Daily Exposure
The real danger of subway air is what it does over years. Long-term exposure to PM2.5 and other pollutants can lead to serious health problems. These include heart disease, lung cancer, and other respiratory diseases. It can even shorten your life (New York City subways expose commuters to toxic air).
For Black and Hispanic riders who face more exposure, the risks are even higher. This extra pollution burden adds to other health disparities these communities already face. It’s a hidden factor that can affect overall community health for years to come (NYC subway riders exposed to toxic air: Study).
MTA and Air Quality: Responses and Responsibilities
Current MTA Stance on Air Quality Issues
The MTA’s response to air quality concerns has been mixed. When faced with the study results, MTA Communications Director Tim Minton dismissed them. He claimed the research was “debunked” and stressed how public transit helps fight climate change (NYC subway riders exposed to toxic air: Study).
This response shows a gap between scientific findings and MTA actions. While public transit is good for the environment overall, that doesn’t erase the air quality problem underground. The MTA seems to be avoiding the issue rather than tackling it head-on.
Here’s what the MTA has said about air quality:
- Question the study’s methods
- Point out the environmental benefits of mass transit
- Haven’t announced any major plans to improve air quality
- Suggest more research is needed
Potential Solutions and Challenges
Fixing subway air quality won’t be easy or cheap. But there are things the MTA could do:
- Improve ventilation in stations and tunnels
- Use cleaner train brakes that produce less dust
- Clean stations and tracks more often
- Install air filters in trains and on platforms
- Use electric or cleaner-burning maintenance vehicles
The biggest challenge is money. These changes would cost a lot, and the MTA is already short on cash. There’s also the question of how to fix things without disrupting service. Riders need clean air, but they also need trains that run on time (NYC Subway Riders Ingest ‘Exceptionally High’ Amounts of Air Pollution Every Day).
Public Transit and Climate Change Impact
The Role of Subways in Reducing Overall Emissions
Subways play a big role in fighting climate change. They move lots of people without using much fuel per person. This cuts down on car emissions and helps keep city air cleaner overall. In fact, cities with good public transit tend to have lower carbon footprints (NYC subway riders exposed to toxic air: Study).
But this good news comes with a catch. While subways help above ground, they create their own pollution problems below. It’s a tricky balance. We need subways to fight climate change, but we also need to make them safer for riders.
Balancing Environmental Benefits with Health Concerns
The subway air quality issue shows how complex environmental problems can be. On one hand, subways are great for the planet. On the other, they’re exposing millions to toxic air. This is especially unfair to Black and Hispanic riders who face the worst exposure (New York City subways expose commuters to toxic air).
Solving this will take creative thinking. We need to keep the environmental benefits of subways while fixing the air quality problem. This might mean:
- Investing in cleaner subway technology
- Redesigning stations for better air flow
- Using air cleaning systems in trains and stations
- Rethinking how we plan transit routes to reduce exposure for vulnerable groups
The goal should be a subway system that’s good for the planet and safe for all riders, no matter their race or where they live (NYC Subway Riders Ingest ‘Exceptionally High’ Amounts of Air Pollution Every Day).
FAQ
Q: What is the main concern regarding air quality in New York City’s subway system?
A: The subway system exposes riders to alarming levels of air pollution, with air on platforms being ten times more polluted than safe levels, severely impacting Black and Hispanic riders the most.
Q: Why are Black and Hispanic subway riders more affected by air pollution?
A: Black and Hispanic commuters face much worse air quality due to longer commutes, living farther from jobs, and spending more time on polluted platforms, breathing in 35% more polluted air than Asian workers and 23% more than white workers.
Q: What health risks are associated with breathing subway air?
A: Short-term effects include asthma attacks and difficulty breathing, while long-term exposure can lead to serious health issues like heart disease and cancer, primarily due to tiny PM2.5 particles.
Q: What are PM2.5 particles, and why are they a concern?
A: PM2.5 particles are tiny pollutants that can penetrate deep into the lungs and bloodstream. They originate from various sources in the subway, such as brake dust and outdoor pollution, and breathing them in can cause severe health impacts.
Q: How do subway air quality levels compare to outdoor air?
A: Subway air is often far more polluted than outdoor air. PM2.5 levels in New York’s subway are significantly higher than the safe limits recommended by the World Health Organization.
Q: What actions has the MTA taken regarding subway air quality?
A: The MTA has provided mixed responses, questioning the study’s validity and emphasizing the environmental benefits of transit. They have not announced significant plans to address the underground air quality issue.
Q: What potential solutions exist for improving subway air quality?
A: Possible solutions include improving ventilation, using cleaner train technologies, installing air filters, and enhancing cleaning protocols, though financial constraints present a significant challenge.
Q: How can air pollution in the subway link to broader climate issues?
A: While subways help reduce carbon emissions overall, the pollution they create underground poses significant health risks. Balancing environmental benefits with the health needs of riders, particularly marginalized communities, is essential for future improvements.
ABOUT THE AUTHOR
Darius Spearman is a professor of Black Studies at San Diego City College, where he has been teaching since 2007. He is the author of several books, including Between The Color Lines: A History of African Americans on the California Frontier Through 1890. You can visit Darius online at africanelements.org.